Gauchers 2020 Top

Ten Minute Halacha - Standing for the Reading of Aseres Hadibros

Ask speaker
Feb 2, 2010
11 min 59 sec

Series: Ten Minute Halacha

Venue: DRS Yeshiva High School for Boys DRS Yeshiva High School for Boys


More from this:
1 comment
Leave a Comment
  1. Title: Upper or Lower Notes
    Author: Chaim Simons ,

    For shuls who always lein the aseres hadibros with the “ta’am hoelyon”, one could argue that one stands during the reading, since the sound of the leining is different from other parts of the Torah, especially at the end of each dibrah. This is admittedly not a strong argument, but maybe one can make a comparison with “oz yoshir” which is leined to a special tune and one stands. On Shavuos, there is an additional reason to stand when reading the aseres hadibros, namely, that this Festival marks the anniversary of receiving the Torah.  However, according to “Luach l’Eretz Yisroel” of Rav Tukachinski, one only uses the “ta’am hoelyon” on Shavuos, but for the parshios Yisro and Voeschanan, he writes that one reads the aseres hadibros, as for other parts of the Torah, namely with the “ta’am  hatachton”. Since the above two reasons for standing do not apply on these two Shabbosos, it could therefore be argued that one should remain seated.

Learning on the Marcos and Adina Katz YUTorah site is sponsored today by Philip & Tamar Gross lilui nishmas their grandparents Rachel Leah bas Menachem HaKohen and Simcha Ben Tuvya whose yahrzeits are this week and by the Lazor and Warren families l'ilui nishmas Leba bas Mechanem Mendel HaLevi on her 12th yartzheit and in memory of Elaine Bienenfeld Silver z”l by her children and grandchildren and by the Gottlieb and Moise Families in memory of David Gottlieb